Hjarki Posted October 25 Share Posted October 25 I'm curious why either Radiation or Electric would be superior to Bio in terms of Tanker farming. All of them can hard-cap S/L resist. Bio has the easiest time soft-capping S/L def. Bio has a damage aura like Electric, but it also has a -resist aura. Bio also has a -damage aura, +health/regen and +damage. While Electric and Radiation have +recharge, noprmally this has a trivial effect on damage once you're fully slotted up. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Maelwys Posted October 25 Share Posted October 25 9 hours ago, Hjarki said: I'm curious why either Radiation or Electric would be superior to Bio in terms of Tanker farming. For AFK Farming, you definitely need two damage auras and any additional passive Global Recharge is extra useful (to buff the one single clicky PBAoE attack that you get to put on autofire) - so Elec has the edge there. And it's also got a few extra places in those passive powers to stick useful self-buffing procs (e.g power transfer) For Active Farming, Rad wins but Beta Decay's Recharge buff is almost an afterthought. The main draw is Radiation Decay and Ground Zero because when procced up those two clickies can take out entire spawns by themselves; and you simply never need to worry about Regeneration or Recovery. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Speed Freak Posted October 26 Share Posted October 26 (edited) Forgive me if this is the wrong place for this, I'll delete the post if so. I'm looking to up my farming game and am looking for some advice from the pro's. Not knowing any better, and looking at 4 year old posts I built a Spines/Fire Brute as my farmer. Then a "knowledgeable" SG member helped me respec him. I am not getting anywhere NEAR the numbers I see posted here. Don't get me wrong, I'm not looking for cutting edge, nosebleed return on investments, but it would be nice to be able to flex a little. This is the build I'm currently using, I have about 350 million Inf tucked away for a rainy day. Is there anything I can do to improve him? Farmer - Hero BruteBuild plan made with Mids' Reborn v3.7.5 rev. 21 ────────────────────────────── Primary powerset: Spines Secondary powerset: Fiery Aura Pool powerset (#1): Concealment Pool powerset (#2): Leaping Pool powerset (#3): Leadership Pool powerset (#4): Fighting Epic powerset: Psionic Mastery ────────────────────────────── Powers taken: Level 1: Lunge (Empty) Level 1: Fire Shield A: Aegis: Resistance/Endurance 3: Aegis: Resistance/Recharge 3: Aegis: Endurance/Recharge 5: Aegis: Resistance/Endurance/Recharge 5: Aegis: Resistance Level 2: Blazing Aura A: Scirocco's Dervish: Damage/Endurance 11: Scirocco's Dervish: Damage/Recharge 11: Scirocco's Dervish: Accuracy/Damage 13: Scirocco's Dervish: Accuracy/Damage/Endurance 13: Scirocco's Dervish: Chance of Damage(Lethal) Level 4: Spine Burst A: Obliteration: Accuracy/Damage/Endurance/Recharge 45: Obliteration: Accuracy/Recharge 48: Obliteration: Damage/Recharge 48: Obliteration: Accuracy/Damage/Recharge 48: Obliteration: Damage Level 6: Healing Flames A: Panacea: Heal 7: Panacea: Heal/Endurance 7: Panacea: Endurance/Recharge 9: Panacea: Heal/Recharge 9: Panacea: Heal/Endurance/Recharge Level 8: Stealth A: Luck of the Gambler: Defense/Increased Global Recharge Speed 25: Red Fortune: Defense 25: Red Fortune: Defense/Endurance 27: Red Fortune: Defense/Recharge 27: Red Fortune: Endurance/Recharge 29: Red Fortune: Defense/Endurance/Recharge Level 10: Grant Invisibility A: Luck of the Gambler: Defense/Increased Global Recharge Speed Level 12: Infiltration A: Luck of the Gambler: Defense/Increased Global Recharge Speed Level 14: Temperature Protection A: Aegis: Resistance 15: Aegis: Resistance/Endurance 15: Aegis: Resistance/Recharge 21: Aegis: Endurance/Recharge 21: Aegis: Resistance/Endurance/Recharge Level 16: Plasma Shield A: Aegis: Resistance/Endurance 17: Aegis: Resistance/Recharge 17: Aegis: Endurance/Recharge 19: Aegis: Resistance/Endurance/Recharge 19: Aegis: Resistance Level 18: Quills A: Obliteration: Accuracy/Damage/Endurance/Recharge 42: Obliteration: Damage 42: Obliteration: Damage/Recharge 43: Obliteration: Accuracy/Damage/Recharge 45: Obliteration: Accuracy/Recharge Level 20: Combat Jumping A: Luck of the Gambler: Defense/Increased Global Recharge Speed 23: Red Fortune: Defense 23: Red Fortune: Defense/Endurance 46: Red Fortune: Defense/Recharge 46: Red Fortune: Endurance/Recharge 46: Red Fortune: Defense/Endurance/Recharge Level 22: Consume A: Panacea: Heal 34: Panacea: Heal/Endurance 37: Panacea: Endurance/Recharge 39: Panacea: Heal/Recharge 39: Panacea: Heal/Endurance/Recharge Level 24: Ripper A: Obliteration: Accuracy/Damage/Endurance/Recharge 43: Obliteration: Damage 43: Obliteration: Damage/Recharge 45: Obliteration: Accuracy/Damage/Recharge 50: Obliteration: Accuracy/Recharge Level 26: Burn A: Superior Avalanche: Accuracy/Damage 37: Superior Avalanche: Damage/Endurance 40: Superior Avalanche: Accuracy/Damage/Endurance 40: Superior Avalanche: Accuracy/Damage/Recharge 40: Superior Avalanche: Accuracy/Damage/Endurance/Recharge 42: Superior Avalanche: Recharge/Chance for Knockdown Level 28: Maneuvers A: Luck of the Gambler: Defense/Increased Global Recharge Speed 29: Red Fortune: Defense 31: Red Fortune: Defense/Endurance 31: Red Fortune: Defense/Recharge 31: Red Fortune: Endurance/Recharge 34: Red Fortune: Defense/Endurance/Recharge Level 30: Kick (Empty) Level 32: Tough A: Aegis: Resistance 33: Aegis: Resistance/Endurance 33: Aegis: Resistance/Recharge 33: Aegis: Endurance/Recharge 34: Aegis: Resistance/Endurance/Recharge 39: Gladiator's Armor: TP Protection +3% Def (All) Level 35: Weave A: Reactive Defenses: Defense/RechargeTime 36: Reactive Defenses: Defense/Endurance/RechargeTime 36: Reactive Defenses: Defense 36: Reactive Defenses: Defense/Endurance 37: Reactive Defenses: Endurance/RechargeTime Level 38: Phoenix Rising A: Invention: Recharge Reduction Level 41: Mesmerize (Empty) Level 44: Tactics A: Invention: To Hit Buff Level 47: Harmonic Mind A: Invention: Endurance Modification 50: Invention: Endurance Modification 50: Invention: Endurance Modification Level 49: Build Up A: Invention: Recharge Reduction ────────────────────────────── Inherents: Level 1: Fury Level 1: Brawl (Empty) Level 1: Sprint A: Invention: Run Speed Level 2: Rest A: Invention: Healing Level 1: Swift A: Invention: Flight Speed Level 1: Hurdle A: Invention: Jumping Level 1: Health A: Panacea: +Hit Points/Endurance Level 1: Stamina A: Power Transfer: Chance to Heal Self ──────────────────────────────Incarnates: Agility Core Paragon Ion Radial Final Judgement Paralytic Core Flawless Interface Ageless Core Epiphany Assault Radial Embodiment |MBD;23277;1312;1752;BASE64;| |G+xaAKwKeHMO5cToYFAN3FEqD4sRUbmh8qsRzd8FqNKdKhUzJ1N+GgfC/H+Stdx6hKQ| |7lCFZuvpahwWkq9v0fEY4zTJ/qn1Vvffq3NR7daMekfj9BAmDBXjm9r+/N2MBDQfhX/| |yiAf01pRav5aUWas12Qq1SJtTHA0bv2Tm2sdVgQllcAAsGQsa0+5GuqX0beKAVY+wqP| |gyL3BcV4mkH1mosGflrhUDWtuj8RuNZWy5+GCJVNcLix4LaTvlD1xfn4FRmGzOkpE5e| |h9Rd0pweSoxdaHGl5OpSvCtlVLeYnzVNWF1nJ4S35L2O3P93YcrWRYjOlvq8aPXxkEw| |GPaGy+bmK12hBgd5LDNlqERQqj/cQxBthB7e6EeHap6WZcFV5gbd5VyPF/CpchlZaL7| |b4krNnipuc5Hmp6I3M/vwwVx17L0/d1maseeBHzFnmnIZBkCcISe9+bbvQorf7erq4P| |swSQZ48UoafzUP7Ns9V39M+z7QbAasn9UrLMm++Ve9Dsao/F1M1VVUom9mp9FXg9sv/| |93iFx62FyloYbQ9/tXBP7h/lnL3PAPUt0BEHbpYwx+8HjltGQ8GPwiDgkiQ0rBGrGq9| |wRmumd7itd7FYDBqP4M+wFpPB4OoW+xW3+RQVCT2CIkQ2PUPeV/4rv3em8rvY1UBZ4w| |4Wz9+nTwk/T08yxLPkna/WfX2tuQoYIC6uDlgUGBPdIfJOHkPckVVS4BaLu+pzTMgnd| |sQtOaxnrTAMkQxNQdNggXsPqQOsx4TyRM5xbyy+f59k4xNcKKzQoypBgEKEvgQFlmX+| |CWpqruldYK07u+O+WPy641661cLt/zfo5LmJlaBIBWs8lsw6TizDo7aBXF8YILgsCYw| |QPP2LLm9s7DnUWK3ZBIYQRDk29bieTCwDEwCizb1vdaTzWTRoUI124IZUV46qNTQrYk| |35ARRiy3x+goUVAGdI5Zw8iA54hN/kKJk1n6YwQuT4Gfhe937sd4tqZnXgQDM7ScIAm| |oSmkDQWGWsR9VCXz4OL3ns2UgfUA0OWEaJ/HRxLQVLY2TGlviSFOXpejpdb7okyTITy| |iyAHF36CaWEYYRihGZm4ByaNkrUQ0TvNpzkNTUFTsDRRsIEG9sYbd9gWeLBoQrfV7Qh| |V2/aJCZ5Z2c4bt7JTVxuF2F+QFWQNGEeceg78Vl4Z9KCwUws34GBc2yiSh535ptSXJY| |ERhPsrfJXj3ZeoMb8gAWME1/UKZOphjty+r1s0NkyyIDpbydgTmU9TfgRGAPSXZpVj/| |9Cn8hAujyTE9KAohSN/4GcIsEul6Tf49t1hhL37OqWEFR+tuTpcAQwRXxaqOGsrSfSe| |HZ+3w+S15BDJ+j8Wy+O7A9IrnqfiNub6vpATIe8lM3I9v6xgZep1GMHnqCsZueN2T7e| |kbP/9vRD345GyWgbHbL1RbEQ08GLxhlMFNMMgEPOrqv/QWm+6iRvpXmkU+KB5Ny7hOr| |+faS6+UCbp7ERrqur+TBj8or7OJg52djv9M7V/s9ivbSl9R8hyHBUGxlhr142FrnEZf| |Mqbv+x+kUeKjPXQt00cPXYMhXhG3tqvA0cPZv4KDeHQI0Lj6y6eYixe9/No+tsaRuyg| |k8O40N+QlGJco5lXkXwc6EMcfC2iboPJKu5Nzjx73na+60bFQ1gpxFiptamCkP42qgx| |NDta3kjP2R4fyiyKTLmWqkFQZ8qG3VuOC3l4oEipfsm62N927j7cjZPRHYBmmoDjA5+| |FDEk9RAw==| Edited October 26 by Speed Freak Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Maelwys Posted October 26 Share Posted October 26 (edited) 9 hours ago, Speed Freak said: Forgive me if this is the wrong place for this, I'll delete the post if so. I'm looking to up my farming game and am looking for some advice from the pro's. Not knowing any better, and looking at 4 year old posts I built a Spines/Fire Brute as my farmer. Then a "knowledgeable" SG member helped me respec him. I am not getting anywhere NEAR the numbers I see posted here. Don't get me wrong, I'm not looking for cutting edge, nosebleed return on investments, but it would be nice to be able to flex a little. This is the build I'm currently using, I have about 350 million Inf tucked away for a rainy day. Is there anything I can do to improve him? The good news is that you're ticked on 90% Fire Resistance and 45% Fire Defense. However you're only pulling around 21 HP/Sec regen when Consume is down (assuming you've gotten your Passive Accolades) so it likely won't survive meteor AFK farming. And your AoE damage slotting is very much lacking for clearing maps quickly in Active Farming (aside from Blazing Aura NONE of your attacks have a single damage proc; and you're missing other important things such as Hasten and a Gaussian Proc in Build Up). You're also missing the Steadfast Protection +Defence; the Reactive Defenses +Resistance, the Shield Wall +Resistance, and the Preventive Maintenance +Absorb Globals; as well as the Miracle +Recovery Proc... and I don't see any Performance Shifters and only one Preventative Maintenance +Healing Procs; at a quick glance. So as it stands your damage output is going to be poor; and you'll only be able to survive if you're Farming lower level enemies or you're actively clicking on Healing Flames. Check AA's post a few thread pages back here which contains example AFK and Active Builds for a Spines/Fire Brute. Note that both sample builds there are also Fire Resist Hardcapped + Fire Softcapped... but the AFK build has much greater passive damage buffs and regeneration; and the active build has far more AoE attacks plus Hasten. Both of them have considerable amounts of Global Recharge and most of their important AoEs are completely laden with damage procs. Ever since the aggro cap behaviour changes it's gotten much tougher for Brutes to survive AFK AE farming; and so realistically you're probably going to have to fork out a fair amount of Inf to get a top-tier Brute build that can manage it (at least with anything approaching acceptable speed - Stone's Granite Form is there as a bargain option!) It's also possible to make a Brute build that is viable in most PVE and can also AFK farm pretty well - but due to the Regeneration requirements your best option there will probably be (non Granite!) Stone Armor. The one I'm currently using on-and-off is Brute - Rad Melee - Stone Armor (Fold Space).mbd - it can handle AFK Fire Farming on meteor farms at +4x8 no problem; if a smidge more slowly than a dedicated AFK-farmer with Assault and procbombed damage auras. I completed it a few months back and it probably cost me ballpark 300m excluding the couple of Winter sets and Boosters - and the toon made that back the first day just by me throwing it into a meteor map every 10mins whilst I was supposed to be working. For ACTIVE farming - there's more leeway in terms of survivability because you're there to activate Heals and clicky buffs on demand. But in those cases you really want to load up on as many big-radius-many-target-cap AoEs as you can and proc them front+back+sideways. Tankers have the advantage there mainly due to Gauntlet's increased Target Cap buff (its radius buff is a smidge less important as it only affects certain AoEs + when farming your targets are usually tightly clustered) If you want to farm with a lower-cost build, honestly I'd go for a Tanker over a Brute any day of the week. It's much easier to hit the important survivability figures (90% res, 45% Def, >35HP/Sec Regen) on a Tanker, which gives a lot more wiggle room for slotting or power picks that aren't bleeding-edge min-maxxed. Edited October 26 by Maelwys 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Hjarki Posted October 27 Share Posted October 27 (edited) On 10/25/2024 at 3:20 PM, Maelwys said: For AFK Farming, you definitely need two damage auras and any additional passive Global Recharge is extra useful (to buff the one single clicky PBAoE attack that you get to put on autofire) - so Elec has the edge there. And it's also got a few extra places in those passive powers to stick useful self-buffing procs (e.g power transfer) Let's assume +100% global recharge and +25% global damage. Electric's Atom Smasher would be 81.886 * 1.25 / (3.168 + 22/2.2) = 7.77 dps. Bio's Atom Smasher would be 81.886 * 1.5 / (3.168 + 22 / 2) * 1.06916 = 9.27 dps. 6 procs in Atom Smasher would be 71.75 * 3.5 * (22 + 2.93) / 60 / 2.125 * 6) / (3.168 + 22/2.2) = 22.37 dps for Electric and 71.75 * 3.5 * (22 + 2.93) / 60 / 2.125 * 6) / (3.168 + 22/2) * 1.06916 = 22.23 dps for Bio. Electric's Irradiated Ground would be 6.8845 * 2 * 1.25 / 2 + 71.75 * 3.5 / 60 / 2.125 * 6 = 20.42 dps. Bio's Irradiated Ground would be (6.8845 * 2 * 1.5 / 2 + 71.75 * 3.5 / 60 / 2.125 * 6) * 1.06916 = 23.68 dps. Lightning Field would do (10.5659 * 2.25 / 2 + 3.5 / 60 / 1.9 * 71.75 * 4) = 20.70 dps. Genetic Contamination would do (7.9245 * 2.5 / 2 + 3.5 / 60 / 1.9 * 71.75 * 4) * 1.06916 = 20.01 dps. DNA Siphon would deal (26.419 * 1.9 + .9 * 71.75 * 5) / (1.848 + 90 / 2) * 1.06916 = 8.51 dps. Bio can also slot a Psionic damage proc in Evolving Armor for another +2.20 dps. Dragon's Tail, assuming automatic proc of FF, would deal (62.4341 * 1.25 + 71.75 * 3.5 * (14 + 1.5) / 60 / 1.9 * 5) / (1.716 + 14 / 3.35) = 42.20 dps. Radiation Therapy would deal (23.7734 * 1.65 + 71.75 * .9 * 5) / (1.188 + 60 / 3.35) = 18.96 dps Ground Zero would deal (105.6597 * 1.25 + 71.75 * .9 * 6) / (3.168 + 90 / 3.35) = 17.30 dps So: Electric = 7.77 + 22.37 + 20.42 + 20.70 = 71.26 dps Bio = 9.27 + 22.23 + 23.68 + 20.01 = 75.19 dps, or 75.1 + 8.51 = 83.61 dps active Radiation = 42.40 + 18.96 + 17.30 = 78.66 dps Note that Radiation would have a substantial advantage against 10+ targets. Additional Notes: Contrast Dark vs. Electric. Electric's +20% recharge is only worth about 2.12 dps (it only impacts the portion of damage from Atom Smasher). Dark has the same damage aura, but it also has two other auras that can slot procs (3 procs in Cloak of Fear, 1 proc in Oppressive Gloom) - and even a single extra proc outweighs the value of that +20% recharge. Given that Dark also has a +5% defense toggle (which makes building a farmer significantly easier) and it has potential proc bomb heal if you're so inclined, I'd argue that Dark is almost strictly superior to Electric for this purpose. On the active farming front, consider Staff. If I ran the numbers right, 6 proc Guarded Spin (on Radiation Armor) does 46.91 dps and 6 proc Innocuous Strikes does 49.87 dps. While they're only 10 targets, that's still an enormous disparity in potential dps between this sort of set and Martial Arts - especially when you consider we haven't yet talked about the third AE in the set (a PBAoE KB attack). For that matter, Ripper runs about 50.56 dps with 5 procs and is as reliable as Dragon's Tail for generating FF procs. It's also in a set with a damage aura and large radius PBAoE to add even more damage. A build like Radiation/Spines seems like it would be directly superior to Radiation/MA for the purposes of active farming. Edited October 28 by Hjarki Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Speed Freak Posted October 27 Share Posted October 27 Uhhhh....what's a meteor farm? 😆 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Maelwys Posted October 28 Share Posted October 28 (edited) 2 hours ago, Hjarki said: Let's assume +100% global recharge and +25% global damage. Don't forget that you need substantially higher S/L resistance with Bio Armor + Offensive Adaption enabled compared to Elec Armor. You could certainly take AA's Page5 A/L AFK build and swap out Elec Armor for Bio Armor with a few minor tweaks (see below) however as soon as you toggle on Offensive Adaption your S/L resistance is going to be sitting well below the 90% mark. (That said I did manage to rejiggle some slots and gain it back at the expense of a little Recharge/Regen/Recovery though - see build #2 - so whatever floats your boat I guess?)AA_AFK_SL_Page5.mbd - Original Elec Armor buildAA_AFK_SL_Page5-Bio1.mbd - Bio Armor Build #1, slight tweaks only.AA_AFK_SL_Page5-Bio2.mbd - Bio Armor Build #2, more tweakage for Offensive Adaption. Edited October 28 by Maelwys Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Maelwys Posted October 28 Share Posted October 28 2 hours ago, Speed Freak said: Uhhhh....what's a meteor farm? 😆 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Speed Freak Posted October 28 Share Posted October 28 Maelwys and Hjarki, thank you. 350 million tucked away for a rainy day turned into just over 500 mil scraped from every available source AND some grind farming for the rest but I now have Angels AFK Spines/Fire build. Wow. Just...wow. 😁 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
easykillforyou Posted October 28 Share Posted October 28 Unable to find the data/texts/English/menus in my directory. Data folder is empty with no hidden files Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
CrowcusPocus Posted November 2 Share Posted November 2 What's the go-to Alpha these days? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
DarknessEternal Posted Wednesday at 09:03 PM Share Posted Wednesday at 09:03 PM On 11/2/2024 at 7:22 AM, CrowcusPocus said: What's the go-to Alpha these days? Always Musculature Core. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Sanguinesun Posted Thursday at 04:19 AM Share Posted Thursday at 04:19 AM On 11/2/2024 at 9:22 PM, CrowcusPocus said: What's the go-to Alpha these days? It is going to depend on how you've built your farmer. If you've built well for for your res and def etc already then the best damage oriented alpha would be a logical choice. However if you still have/need a reliance on some other deficit in the build due, then you may have to make other choices. People for example sometimes make builds strongly focused on damage, but then neglect endurance needs, acc, and more. Its always about the recipe, not one specific ingredient. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now