I'm not sure what the time difference makes.
Fair? Who determines what's fair? That I had enough foresight and studiously kept my XML files backed-up on four different drives for over six years, it wouldn't be fair to anyone else to restore my hard-earned character because someone else didn't do it? No, not new....restored. I earned those level 50 characters...I put in the time, sweat, tears, and laughter.
You see, I would love to be able to play the game like I used to many years ago. In the course of eight years, I racked up over 16,000 hours on one account alone (I only had two accounts). Translate that to years and that's over 1.8 years of solid 24/7 gaming that I put into those characters. There's nothing powerleveled about them. However, I can't play like I used to because after the game shutdown, it forced me out in the sunlight where I found the love of my life, adopted one son and just had my first bio son, and I'm traveling way too much for my job already.
It's going to be a community-based MMO now, we can make our own rules.