I’ve played the set for about 12 levels and my opinions are mixed at best.
Pros
A high damage attack at lvl 1;
A combination self Defense buff and enemy Res debuff at lvl 1;
Access to a high damage knockup cone at lvl 2 (4 for Tanks);
A sometimes-available superior damage knockdown and possible stun at lvl 6 (16 for Tanks) ;
The coolest-looking weapons in the game. You can use a chunk of concrete on a stick, a rocket powered hammer, chainsaw on a stick, a railroad crossing sign… They’re all bad-ass.
The powers work as advertised. TW offers huge burst damage: a Scrapper’s crit with a tier 1 attack will either one-shot a white mob or leave it with a sliver of health you can Brawl away. I’m guessing a Brute with high Fury could lay down glorious amounts of damage. The knock effects are strong and no other set gives you a knockdown cone that early. Plus it looks awesome.
Cons
Sssssllllooooooooowwww. It’s like being debuffed constantly. I shudder to think about what the set is like when actually debuffed. See what I said about Brawl above? You have time to get 3 of those in while waiting for an attack to recharge. In teams I find that my target usually dies before the wind-up is finished. Solo I can take a beating in between swings. A missed attack is heartbreaking.
Momentum is tricky to manage. It’s like Fury but not. I suppose getting used to it requires time. The set has a build-up which grants Momentum on a click but I haven’t used it much yet.
I don’t know what the set is like for Brutes or Tanks. It seems like a Brute might suffer a net Fury loss with the slowest attack chain in the game, but I don’t know if the extra shots enemies get during the wind-ups would make up for it. I think managing both Fury and Momentum would be quite a juggling act. For Tanks I think that waiting until 16 for that 3rd attack would be bothersome since it offers good control that might be needed in early levels.
I don’t know if TW’s trade-offs are worth it in a game where speed can be so important. Slotting would surely help but would it help enough? What are your experiences?