Steampunkette

Shield is a perfectly good set. And it is super easy to softcap it and enjoy the mini-nuke of shield charge. And when shit goes down, One with the Shield is of course wonderful. But it's nothing spectacular. It doesn't excel in any given way over other sets for Brutes. It's really more about theme and style than the min-maxing power available to it, which is what most build discussions on the boards come down to. That said, while Brutes don't benefit from Against All Odds as thoroughly as Scrappers do, it is still a really nice power. It can bring your output up a bit early in a fight and make your Fury somewhat more impressive when you bounce from fight to fight chasing the fury meter. And Shield Charge makes that distance shorter! I love Street Justice and Shields, myself. Particularly how mean some of the attacks can look when combined with a shield. Heavy Blow's left-elbow strike instead smashes someone with the edge of the shield, for example.

So I'm looking at doing a sapper built Dominator. I obviously intend to use the hell out of Conductive Aura to reduce the endurance cost and make it more accurate. Most of the powers in the set reduce the endurance of targets hit by 10%, which means by the time I've fired 5-8 shots at a target they're probably going to be out of endurance and feeding me just a tiny bit. Do you wondrous people think it is a reasonable decision to focus entirely on the AoE controls and slot for endurance modification, skipping out on the Single Target, since stacking controls isn't the goal, and making my attacks all about the damage? I'm on a tablet as I ask this, otherwise I'd pump out a build with SO slotting (Gonna DFB up a bit, but don't have the inf for IOs) for suggestions and number crunching. >.>

Thank you! Your mind is closed. Thank you for making that clear. Ahhh, yes. By declaring that I am closed minded in response to your disrespectful discourse you reject my position without having to discuss or refute the particulars of it while presenting yourself as the egalitarian party who has tried to present reason and been met with stonewalling foolishness. It's remarkably common for women to be shut down like that. Presented as unreasonable or illogical. Didn't expect it to be my second post on the forum that caught -that- particular reaction. Not liking people using Sarcasm to talk down to you in an example of classic infantilization is close mindedness, you heard it here, first, folks!

so basically you're going to be useless forever, got it i'll stick to my VEAT which already does everything this proposal does but better That's a pretty radical interpretation of the text, Solvernia. To not be the best at something does not mean useless. The intent of the archetype is to be flexible, to cover a lot of roles while also allowing for a wide variety of concepts. Wanna be Batman? This would be how to Batman closer than the game otherwise allows. Martial Assault/Gadgetry Command. Maybe pick up the Leadership toggles. Martial Arts, Stun Grenades, Shuriken you can RP are Batarangs, and Super Reflexes to avoid getting hurt. Swap roles to fit different positions on the team and use your leadership buffs at defender levels. Or create your own character concept that's built around being flexible but not built around GUN and CLAWS and SPIDER FASCISTS.

Blazing Command: Fire Shield Fire Cages Healing Flames (PBAoE Heal in Support) Char Plasma Shield Flashfire Hot Feet Cinders Rise of the Phoenix (PBAoE Group Rez, Usable while Down) Earthen Command Rock Armor Stone Cages Fossilize Brimstone Armor Stalagmites Crystal Armor Salt Crystals Minerals Earthquake Energy Command Lift Kinetic Shield Gravity Distortion Power Shield Dimensional Shift Entropic Aura Gravity Distortion Field Energy Drain (PBAoE Endurance Recovery Buff in Support) Overload Frigid Command Ice Slick Frozen Armor Shiver Arctic Air Wet Ice Chilling Embrace Glacial Armor Flash Freeze Glacier Gadgetry Command Focused Fighting Caltrops Wide Area Web Grenade Focused Senses Taser Evasion Stun Grenade Quickness Elude Mental Command Mesmerize Mind Over Body Confuse Indomitable Will High Pain Tolerance Mass Hypnosis Heightened Senses Terrify Strength of Will Natural Command Roots Inexhaustible Hardened Carapace Spore Burst Evolving Armor Ablative Carapace Vines DNA Siphon Seeds of Confusion Shadow Command Dark Embrace Living Shadows Murky Cloud Fearsome Stare Cloak of Darkness Dark Regeneration Heart of Darkness Soul Transfer (PBAoE Group Rez, Usable while Down) Shadowfield Shocking Command Charged Armor Chain Fences Conductive Shield Jolting Chain Tesla Cage Grounded Static Field Power Sink Paralyzing Blast

Instigator: While most superbeing's powers place them within a strong, centralized, role within a superteam, not all are so lucky as to have their powers flow toward a single position, and must instead find their role in a given situation, in a given team, to make it their own. Some choose this flexibility, and find themselves prepared for a variety of situations. These beings, broadly called Instigators, are flexible by nature. They have to be. Primary Powerset: Assault. By using Assault as a primary powerset we place Instigators in a moving position. Some of their abilities require melee, others can be used at range. Some of the Assault sets also lend themselves more heavily toward Melee, Range, or AoE, with some even offering sniper shots. Secondary Powerset: Command. Command Powersets would need to be cobbled together, but could largely be described as a combination of Defensive and Control Powers. 2-3 defensive toggles, perhaps a passive defensive power or two, and the rest control. This places the Instigator in a position between passive and active defenses. Using controls they can lock down some enemies while using their toggles to help reduce damage from those they cannot stop. Inherent Power: Stalwart, Striker, Support Three mutually exclusive toggle powers which cost no endurance and each causing different changes to the character's abilities and attributes, similar to the Dual Pistols ammo toggles. While the Stalwart toggle is active, the Instigator's Command powers have greater effects. It increases the magnitude of control powers by 1, uses a higher defensive value from the toggle powers than normal, and gains increased aggro generation. For example Focused Fighting might provide +10% defense to melee would instead provide +15% while Stalwart is active. While the Striker toggle is active, the Instigator's Assault powers have greater effects. Specifically, the damage of their attacks will have a second value 20% higher than the base value of the attack which is only used while Striker is active. While the Support toggle is active, each of the Instigator's toggled powers is partially shared with allies within a short range of themselves. This is done through an aura function that only activates while Support is in use. Further, their attacks have a chance to proc a small targeted AoE healing effect around their enemy. Proposed NEW Powersets: Blazing Command (Fire Armor/Fire Control) Earthen Command (Stone Armor/Earth Control) Energy Command (Energy Armor/Gravity Control) Frigid Command (Ice Armor/Ice Control) Gadgetry Command (Super Reflexes/Gadget Control Powers)* Mental Command (Willpower/Mind Control) Natural Command (Bio Armor/Plant Control) Shadow Command (Dark Armor/Darkness Control) Shocking Command (Electric Armor/Electric Control) *Gadget Control Powers would be things like Caltrops, Smoke Grenades, Web Grenades, and Tasers. Powers taken from other sources to be combined with Super Reflexes into a Command Powerset. I'll make a second post in this thread to outline the individual powers I recommend. Archetype Scaling: Damage: 0.85 Melee, 0.85 Ranged Hit Points: 1.25 Support: 1.0 Control: 1.0 So what we have is a character who deals roughly Tanker level damage with a Scrapper's hit points and defense values slightly lower than a scrapper (10% compared to 13% for example). They have good control duration but don't have comprehensive control effects or high magnitudes, and while they're very supportive they lack any powers whatsoever which provide heals, buffs, or debuffs. They're very close to Peacebringers or Warshades in values, actually. Once they flick on the Stalwart Toggle, though, their defensive powers increase to be closer to Tanker, somewhere between Scrapper and Tanker. And while that's not enough to make them equivalent to either, their control effects also increase in magnitude, giving them the ability to lock down foes more effectively and often. Once they flick on the Striker Toggle, though, their damage values for melee and ranged attacks leap up to very near Dominator levels (0.85 x 1.2 = 1.02) which are a bit below Blaster levels. But since both values are the same, they're more effective than a Dominator when fighting enemies at range. Once they flick on the Support Toggle they can provide aid to melee or ranged characters by choosing where to fight. If they hang back and focus on ranged attacks and controls, they're able to provide defensive buffs to the Defenders/Sentinels/Blasters/Controllers/Etc while throwing some small amount of healing to the melee characters. Or they can be in the melee stack providing PBAoE buffs and some small healing as a melee-support character. This is a character archetype that can be played Sentinel-esque by throwing on the Striker toggle and never turning it off. It can be played as a mid-ranged off-tank (Or Tanker, with the right buffs!). It can be played as a more damage-oriented Controller with the Stalwart Toggle. Or it can be played as a new melee-support and ranged-support class. All depending on which powers are chosen, what they choose to slot for, and how they use their inherent power. One Archetype. Three Toggles. Multiple Roles. Evolving as the situation changes, responding to each circumstance, and finding a niche in every team they join because their powers are varied enough to work with different concepts. Hanging with a Mastermind and a Dominator? Pop on the Support Toggle to buff the minions as you bash heads in melee and fling extra layers of Mez onto the battlefield. Scrapper and Stalker? Flip on Striker and help them slaughter everything before it can take a swing. Brute just went down and the Tanker is 60 yards back resting during an ITF? Flip into Stalwart and gather up some aggro while locking down a lieutenant that might screw up your Corrupter. You'll never be as good at a given role as someone of the appropriate archetype, because you'll lack comprehensive power options. You'll never be a Controller or Dominator 'cause you just don't have enough holds to lock down the group. You won't have Aim or Build Up to spike like a Blaster and your ranged attack options are limited. You may get a few defensive powers but you'll never be as unkillable as a Tanker or Brute. And even when you slip into Support Mode you won't have the Buff/Debuff/Heals of a devoted Defender or Corruptor. But you can bridge some gaps your group might have. Or double up on some coverage while still finding your specific niche.

Use Air Superiority on a -10 (or better yet, -49) mob sometime. Tell me where the overhead strike of Air Superiority sends them. Go on ... take your time ... I'm in no rush. Your sarcastic memeing is not conducive to continued constructive discussion. Air Superiority's function is to be used in the air on a flying opponent and send them crashing to the ground. The mechanical Kludge used in the beginning of the game was a knock power and people loved it so they never changed it. Yes. Due to the limitation of the game's engine this results in hilarious consequences when used against significantly weaker opponents who are standing on solid ground. But used in the air it still just drops them from flight like ragdolls, no matter how large your level-disparity is.

I would happily accept Kheldian knockback being reduced to KnockDOWN on some of their attacks. But. There are only a handful of characters in this game that can enjoy the satisfying level of flinging their enemies across the battlefield with big hard-striking attacks. It's also something many players push to remove from the game, entirely, due to the frustration it causes them. To me, there is very little in this game that feels more dramatic than a permahastened perma-lightform Peacebringer throwing big and wild knockbacks into a group of enemies and watching them flail through the air, helplessly ragdolling, before the sheer power being used against them crushed them against a wall in a useless pile. One of my most important characters was a Peacebringer. And without that raw sense of power, she would not have felt half as impressive. And no. KnockUP would not replicate that feeling. If anything it'd look freaking weird. Yeah, Warshades do a lot of gravity style control stuff 'cause it's what they're meant to evoke. Peacebringers aren't their "Opposite", it's not a binary. And smashing you in the face with a big rising double-fisted overhead strike should not cause you to spontaneously leap up to smash your face to the ceiling.