Why Brute over Scrapper? Just wondering, because that chance t crit and do double damage sounds really nice.
While talking about creation, does the source of my powers matter in any way? What's the difference between choosing magic or tech?
I will just refer you back to my first comment.
"I've not rolled a lot of melee character..."
:D
To me Cap seems more like a Brute than a Scrapper (I see Brutes as falling in between Scrappers and Tanks). Also, please explain the Crit Chance and double damage you mentioned in your post. I couldn't find a reference in the wiki for the classes, and I didn't see anything in the (i)nfo provided in the powers during creation.