Yeah, it's a VERY weird discussion. When people on Reddit, these forums, or in help chat ask for the strongest melee builds, do the responses contain Super Strength? Not all. Spines/Fire, Electric/Shield, whatever/whatever--but not SS. Where are the nerf calls for the sets that create the most effective melee builds in the game? But instead of looking at the over-performers, a number of posters in this thread want to take an already mediocre set and make it weaker.
That depends on which AT the powersets take.
Without a doubt that Spine/Fire is a Brute favored (farm-)set, while Electric/Shield gives Scrappers the most benefit in terms of burst.
While the latter is something that is accepted, the former is that Brutes are able to completely replace the tankers after a certain level and outperform them vastly due to Fury.
But that's another issue for a different thread.