Riverdusk

Or just ask first. Or just watch for a while and see how they react to other people offering advice. There will always be someone, it's human nature, and then you aren't the one being yelled at.

Sounds you are talking mostly about in a Twitch stream or something. Problem is that is very much going to vary depending on the streamer and it is their stream, so their rules, "consensus" doesn't matter. Some don't like ANY directions, others are much more lax. I do agree with you there is a difference between technical gameplay reminders compared to story spoilers or more directly telling them how to play. As said though, some don't want anything at all, no matter how simple.

Strongly in charge of this one, if for nothing else because the gfx have always been a bit broken. Although I think it is specifically for any tohit or defense buff on a character, because I see it happen with inspirations too. You end up with little floating white rectangles inside a character model when you have such buffs and you are also stealthed (translucent). It almost looks like missing textures or something. At least, that's what I always see, and have always found it minorly annoying.

Can't say I've ever tried it, but in my experience phantasm tends to be quite squishy, unless you have a secondary that is really powerful defensively (like /dark). I wouldn't say FFG would cut it so I'd expect him to die when he goes into melee with enflame on. For a lot of secondaries I treat him more as a short term pet and recast him about as often as I do phantom army. Just an assumption though, maybe someone else has actually tried it. Or if you do try, let us know how it works out. 😀

Resistance can just as easily be the way to go imho. That bodyguard mode is resistance allows you to stack it and maximize it. If you are at 75% resistance and in full bodyguard mode (also 75% resistance) you are effectively at 93.75% resistance (only taking 25% of 25%), which is actually higher than a tank can achieve. Main drawback as usual is you are potentially being hit with all the mez and debuffs. Often I will go for a resistance epic and still aim for a moderate amount of defense (25-30% or so) and it seems to serve me well. Usually easy to keep a few medium purples handy when things get rough. It is also usually easier to aim for positional instead of typed that way, which I find more powerful. Anyway, as a marine being able to summon sharks is just too tempting and leviathan's shield is a resistance one. 😁

I think the fact that it does knockdown takes the edge of danger off it a lot. You can jump in with it, knock most things down, and jump right back out before they can even stand back up if you don't want to stay in melee. The bubbles even give you extra jump. I'd say the only one it might mess with is the hover blaster style, which I really don't do. Even then I'd think you could hover back up out of range while they are knocked down? I do find myself doing a lot of jumping around on my thugs/marine MM with the set. Still less than I probably do with my dominators though. Probably the biggest reason is less the danger and more that in order to use the heal you do have to be somewhat at range since it is a cone. Whitecap and soothing aura definitely work somewhat at odds. I think the devs like to encourage players to move around though, always have.

Even its proc chance doesn't seem great (31% with no slotted recharge, if Mids is to be believed). I went ahead and took it anyway though and just threw an accuracy and an achilles heel in it. I figure I can spam it once I have enough global recharge to keep the -resistance proc up fairly well on a decent number of mobs. It also does help me hit things with plasmatic taser which is my guilty pleasure of a START temp power I like to throw around. Definitely skippable though. Probably most disappointing to me is that its slow doesn't even include -recharge, it is only -speed.

Interesting, I always recommend /time as a secondary for new MM players when they ask for a suggestion and I think it works great for any primary. I find it is one of the strongest sets, and definitely one of the easiest sets to play. It's +recharge might not help, but it has solid defense (and -tohit), solid control, and strong AoE healing. Also a ton of -recharge which is a great "defense" of its own for MM pets. You can actually stack distortion fields, which I find a bit crazy. Farsight also has +tohit and benefits from power boost (unlike FFG), so it actually has a bigger potential than FFG by a decent amount. Then there's its movement slows. I think especially for newbie MM's one of the most common times for things to go sideways is when mobs run off and scatter which then causes your henchmen to scatter after them if you aren't quick to control them. All the slows keep things nice and bunched and controlled, both the enemies and the henchmen. Creates one of the smoother mastermind experiences. I know thugs/time was a FOTM around here at one point for how strong it was considered although I think that has faded now since thugs weren't included in the last round of buffs. Edit: And back to the OP, I would recommend a beast/time, would make a great MM for a first timer. I had one and found it very good.

I'd just nit pick on the word "far" behind the other sets. I'd say more like slightly behind. The MM primaries are closer balanced by far than they have ever been now. What I considered "far" behind is what mercs used to be before their buff. I have a beast/cold myself that seems to compete fairly well with any of my other MM's, although can't say I'm one to crunch the numbers or run trapdoor time trials or anything.

Pro is that their defense can be capped early. Con is all you pretty much get is defense and with thugs the amount of defense you get often ends up being overkill. As others have said, time also gives you enough to more than cap their defense and comes with other things. /Cold is another one that has more than enough and adds other things. /Traps another one if you really want the mez resistance. If I'm calculating correct you can get thugs to about 40% or so defense without any secondary, assuming you slot enforcers for defense, use the pet +def IO's, and use maneuvers. So, you don't need a whole lot more to cap them from any secondary. Although having more from a secondary does save you some slots here and there and allows for some overcapping to help in some situations. Still, as always, if you really dig the combo, there is nothing wrong with it and it should do fine.

I wouldn't mind it being changed to knockdown by default. However, it is one of the easier knockbacks to control as you can choose a destination (into a corner), or you can hover and do the old aim them straight down into the floor trick to limit scatter.

From the thread title I thought this was going to be a suggestion on changing the Infiltration power. I was click baited. 😀

Open up email, start new email, drag a merit from salvage to attachment box (which autofills your global for you to assure there is 0% chance for mistake), type in inf amount, type 1 letter into message box, send. Works for me, but I guess I don't do it often enough that I ever worried about a macro for doing it. Best tip I ever got was attaching a merit to autofill my global, as I was always paranoid about mistyping it. I find it faster than doing the reply method and it doesn't clutter my inbox.

Actually shadowfall also doesn't suppress on attack (only on clicking glowies, same as SI). You can easily monitor that in combat attributes (under PvE stealth) and see that the 35 feet worth doesn't go away when you attack. It is just that Shadowfall's stealth is less, so you are still seen if you get too close to a secondary group. With SI you can literally stand inside a second group while attacking a different group and have the second group not react. Shadowfall is the way to go though anyway. Like said, It being AoE and its resistance buffs are too nice. Then just use a stealth IO in sprint or wherever (which does stack with shadowfall) and still get enough stealth to be invisible in most cases.

I'll go briefly into my usual controller AoE hold rant yet again. Several AT's have nukes which can basically wipe out an entire group of enemies and also often have their own mez/debuff effects for any that survive, recharge in roughly half the time, AND they actually have an accuracy BONUS. Controllers get an accuracy penalty, have double the recharge time, and all it does is hold them, rather than outright defeat them. At the very least they should have roughly the same recharge as a nuke and drop the accuracy penalty. Only 'advantage' would be they are typically available at a lower level than the nukes. If necessary push them all up to a higher level. The rare times I do take them I tend to leave them to later in a build anyway. I'd rather have more useful powers available at lower levels.

You left out stalker. That's the one I tried (ice/ice which several in the stalker forums raved about) and I found the same for them as well. Tried it to the mid 30's or so and pretty well IO'd up for that level. I found ice armor definitely felt among the weakest I've tried for stalkers. It can succeed, because as long as you don't crank the difficulty up too much, almost anything can succeed. However, on a relative basis compared to other defensive sets, I found it lacking. Ice patch (from ice melee and not the armor) was often more the saving grace. Specifically, Ice/Invuln, Ice/Shield, Ice/Energy, all felt so much sturdier at similar levels.

Another way to stop them from MoG is to sap their endurance. Something my electric blast sentinel can do pretty easily and even on multiple at once. Actually have an easier time with them on my electric sentinel than I do with my controllers. Can also use knockdown/knockback if you time it right. Reducing the MoG time a bit wouldn't be terrible, but I'd hate to see them nerfed too much. As others said, it gives some usefulness to things beyond the usual "moar damage=answer to everything." And it isn't like enough burst damage isn't also good enough still anyway.

Yep, beasts are the only one I think could still use a slight boost, but even they aren't as bad as some seem to say, imo. The disparities between the different MM sets isn't near as bad as it used to be. On the other hand I'd agree it is always nice to have a bit more slotting options for powers.

Also on further thought, at least some sort of sleep and possibly stun protection/resistance also makes sense in a thematic/roleplaying sense. A buff that is throwing water on a person is going to wake them up and keep them awake for a while, no? Also could be argued would snap them out of a stupor (stun). So, maybe leave hold and other mezzes as a 'hole' for balance and just give some sleep and stun resistance/protection. Would be similar to Storm's O2 Boost power. Could slide it right in to soothing wave as just one possible spot for it.

Dark, time, and radiation all have solid defense and/or tohit debuff which means mez are much less likely to hit in the first place. Radiation also has solid mez resistance which is what I was saying would be a nice addition.

Some have commented on the lack of any protection against mezzes and it being a set with hardly any defense so you can't avoid mezzes by avoiding being hit either. How about instead of mez protection, at least adding some solid mez resistance? I was just bringing up in another thread that radiation emission's accelerate metabolism is the only power in the game right now with significant mez resistance in it. It'd be cool to have another set with a solid mez resistance power. At accelerate metabolism's mez resistance levels (around 200%) I find mezzes last noticeably shorter and it makes them less often a death sentence, but still keeps things "spicy".

Yep, the only characters I really notice mez resistance on to any significant degree currently are my radiation emission ones. Accelerate metabolism gives around 200% mez resistance (varies some with AT), so it is fairly easy to add that to other bonus and get to that 300% level you mentioned. Starts to get you to the point where at least some of the mezzes only last a couple of seconds.

Acrobatics hold protection I actually find more useful and underrated. It is only a tiny amount, but it typically prevents that first hold from mezzing you on a squishie. The whole mez system of the game is honestly probably one of its weaker points. Mez protection should have been a lot more rare, and mez resistance should have been a lot more common (and more powerful). In other words outright immunity should be rare, but ways to greatly reduce mez time should have been the focus imo. The current system is much too binary. However, with the way toggles used to get knocked off instead of just suppressed even from a 1 second mez, it would not have been popular at all to do it that way back in the day. Nothing was more annoying than having to retoggle 8 different toggles after even a brief mez. Even with the detoggle issue fixed though, it isn't like it is going to change at this point. The riot it would cause...

Was thinking the same thing when I saw it. Typically just like -regen, a -hp debuff is only going to really be noticeable against an AV. -267 hp against an AV is virtually worthless. I compare it against incarnate interface degen which gives -1000 hp and can self or group stack up to 4 times for -4000 hp. Now that makes a difference. -267 I find kind of a joke.

Several of the epic MM pools have aoe immobilizes. By the time you hit ITF I'd hope at least a couple of MM's on the team would have one for that problem. I almost always take one (especially on sets like bots or thugs that tend to send things running with their fire patches).