golstat2003

Generation is a problem because it pushes up the cost of items via inflation. Accumulation isn't an issue. I could list all my converted IOs (which I sometimes do) for 5 inf and still make money. The devs have already explained this based on the market data they have access to.

why not just ask for an arachnos based mm primary set?

And I bet the folks complaining about inf generation due to the exploit fix won't bother to read either of these.

Ummm it still isn't. At any level I level faster while doing team content . . . EDIT: If solo were the ideal way we would not have folks asking for DIB, DFB all day every day in LFG.

I'd bet we'd see an increase in reward merits or merits add to content and new and novel ways. But that's a guess with no proof that that's the direction they are going.

And interestingly no purple actually goes for that. I think folks need to be careful what they wish for.

Well no, since they just banned a shit ton of them. Which might explain why I don't see many during my gaming time. But the OP was saying they INCREASED because of the recent change to inf generation. That's a claim that has no basis in reality. Even more so with what you just quoted. I wouldn't think they would want to try to come back just after getting soundly banned.

I think he/she is pretty much pulling it out of one of their orifices. I've seen nothing of gold selling on HC. If he/she knows they can just send it to the devs the sellers will be dealt with. It absolutely has jack shite to do with the exploit the devs just closed. Gold sellers are gonna try to sell gold no matter what the rate of that gold generation is in any game.

I enjoy the combat in COH. I also enjoy the combat in Dark Souls when I want to play that. I didn't enjoy FFXIV.

True. However, as you mentioned I wouldn't add any of the mechanics that FFXIV has to this game. That ship has sailed. For NEW content maybe. EDIT: As an aside I played FFXIV for a about month to give it a fair shot. I didn't find the experience all that enjoyable. Maybe in my younger days sure, now . .. not so much.

what those who play FFXIV are looking for in a game are vastly different than what those who play COH are looking for.

I'm fine with game difficulty as is. Nothing is mandatory and everything thing is appreciated. When I want to play I just ask for a team in LFG, I really don't care what the team make up is. Same if I'm forming a team. Now if I'm doing specific tfs/sfs I might look for specific things depending on the content. However, ever there if you lower the difficulty it's generally okay to run with whatever. I find that absolutely fine.

I wouldn't be opposed to that. Earn enough emps and you can convert them to a Transcendant and send to other 50s that need them.

Nope, no thank you.

If it's for you an exemplar choice (and NOT the team leader) then sure.

Now THAT is how you do ebil. 😄

the only folks who have the data are the devs. Neither of us do. Us arguing back and forth will be pointless. We can agree to disagree. I say that judgment isn't used every mob, you say they are. 🤷‍♂️

To be fair, they have said they would be monitoring the effects of the change.

From what I get from all the dev statements the change was going out no matter what. What exact would you have been testing related to the change?

As far as I'm concerned (and for the good of the release being as bug free as possible) this was the absolute right call. Carry on team.

I'd be down for merits randomly dropping on regular mission completions. Say a 50% chance for 1 merit to drop.

No I'm not. I'm advocating for no changes at all to incarnate powers, period. Folks pushing the idea that judgements are used every mob have yet to show that's a fact. Suggestions for limits on incarnate powers need to show an actual justification with data. Seeing as how only the devs have access to that data, we'll all just have to agree to disagree.

As long as it's all optional, I see no issue.

I think Inventions was what changed the game significantly, not incarnates. That and AT nukes being crashless lead to more blasters taking their nukes and using them. Perma Dom, Max Recharge, Capped Resistance, Capped Defense meant that teams were steam rolling long before incarnates came about. EDIT: The old style (IMO) was waiting for someone to "herd" or "take the alpha strike" / "tank" and then the rest of the team went to work.

That's fine. But I am leery of suggestions that push that old style back when a majority don't seem to enjoy the slower paced style. (I say that as I've yet to see anyone leave a team complaining "we are clearing mobs too fast, bye".) And as you said this is only at the higher levels. It's not even most of the game. And as others have pointed out on this thread we need more than anecdotal evidence that "teams are using judgement every spawn". They're not.