MTeague

While I'm not AGAINST more melee/ranged choices... .... honestly I'd like to see more Controller/Dominator primaries and Dominator secondaries added first. There's already a LOT more choices for the melee types and support types. Show a little love for the Controllers and Doms'.

The memory is kind of fuzzy to me as well, but.... yea probably. Warsong Gulch, etc you faced off against a small number of other players, each faction limited to same number of players.

Actually I believed this thread was for the option to create an OPT IN status for PvP in Non-PvP zones, if, if you're a rogue, can you PvP willing heroes in Atlas Park or Steel Canyon. But that everyone was still unconditonally flagged for PvP upon entering a PvP zone. Which is an entierely separately question from should you have the ability to decline all PvP even in PvP zones. I'm fine with the first, and I would oppose the second, and I don't think I've engaged in actual PvP vs humans once since Homecoming launched.

I've never seen anyone left alone in a WoW pvp zone like Warsong Gulch, Alterac Valley, etc. I have seen people ignored in places like Wintergrasp and Tol Barad once the raids you could do from those zones were out-dated / no longer part of current raid tier. I have, sometimes, seen people left alone if they charged into a city of the opposite city to do Fishing for some of the Fishing achievements. I've also seen the the opposite-faction fishers relentlessly molested until they just logged out dead and tried again in the wee hours of the night. And I've BEEN one of said opposite faction fishers, each time.

“We have really everything in common with America nowadays, except, of course, language.” -Oscar Wilde

am I going to be burned at the stake if I say I use malt vinegar and spicy mustard on fries?

I haven't seen people specifically asking for a "Most Expensive Build" But I do get mildly irked at the "Whats the best X for Y?" "What should I choose for Z?" It's like... Read The Damn Powers. Learn what your slotting options are. You don't HAVE TO use a cookie cutter Mids build someone else did. Figure out what you want to stack, evaluate your IO choices, and build something off the cuff. It's not hard.

I'd think about it, but there's the slight, teensy-weensy problem of that being actually impossible 🙂 I have a Beast/Empath though!

I tend to use Manuvers/Tactics/Assault more than Boxing/Tough/Weave, esp for a Plant Controller, because eveyrthing is going to be Confused or Held or Ragdolled around anyway, AND you have Hurricane on tap for a massive to-hit debuff. May depend how much you plan to team vs solo though.

You say "strange" as if it were a bad thing.... 🙂 I do tend to do some "Garbage of the Month" builds though. People saying Emp's suck to solo? Okay, Redside Empath Defender coming up. People saying Regen Sucks. Savage/Regen brute, rolled. People raggin' on Trick Arrow again? Fire Control/Trick Arrow Praetorian coming right up! I think it's mostly a contrarian "I bet I can make that work" tendancy.

I'm with @SuperPlyx on this one. I'd hate it if my pets just spent their time trying to slowly run away and NOT ATTACKING if the Tsoo or Knives of Artimis toss down caltrops. Or if the Arachnos big humanform robots (ABU's, RBU's whatever they're called) put down some fire on the ground. I want my pets kllling things dead. I will support them by strategic use of my secondary tree, or by use of inspirations, or pool powers, etc. Or, if things are seriously hitting the fan, I will invoke Expiditious Retreat and bravely run away while my pets die for me.... but I want them keeping enemies busy, and killing as many as they can, the whole time. If there's times I want them to move, it's a quick tap-click for me to hit the "Move Here" keybind and select a target location.

Honestly, so many Heroes and Villains (and Menders!! /eye Derek) have been mucking about with time, the reality is nobody on Primal Earth or Preatoria knows what year it is. The entire time vortex is being held together by some duct tape, incarnate threads, and wishful thinking.

I still want a Support/Melee or a Melee/Support AT, so I can use Kinetics and Kinetic Melee together and Power Siphon Siphon Power or Siphon Power Power Siphon chains.

All threads much evenutally coalesce into one of a few categories. So far I've seen them fall into discussion of Star Wars, discussion of Babylon 5, calls to nerf Regen complaints about farming complaints about Knockback bitching about power creep pleas to add more power creep

I liked that AE allowed for player created STORIES. And I've played some that are really very well done. But I don't like that it kept a big chunk of the player base inside one building instead of travelling around the city. It made the city feel.... much less populated. And I was always disappointed by people using customized enemies to be perfectly weak against their strengths. Sure it's efficient, but ... I don't know. I'm one of those people who LIKE fighting Rularru and Awakened and Malta and Carnies though, so it just felt to me like people were robbing themselves of any worthwhile challenge. And I never liked that the farming missions almost never come with a STORY to them. TL;DR: AE can be used for great good as well as endless farming. But not many use it the way I hoped it would be used.

Dying in the Hollows trying to get to a mission as the Pumice / Igneous rock dudes burst out of the earth. Dying on the way back to a second group of them as you tried to avoid the first group. Carefully working your way through Grendel's Gorge back the third time, only to watch a teammate awaken the Pumice / Igneous and being "Oh god! Oh god no!" as you die horribly a third time. Asking yourself why you didn't take Hover, no matter how slow it may be. Eventually getting a Recall Friend to the door.

The striped version works well as a Tom Baker - ish scarf, and monocolor can work nicely as a Lamont Cranston / Shadow look.

I can pretty much guarantee my characters backstories will all expand to consume as much space as I am given. Whether that is 1023 or 2046 or 20,000 or 40,000. So if the limit is expanded by a LOT... it might make sense to leave the existing field in place as a "summary/synopsis" and then a "read more" button to get to the meat and potatoes, so people aren't loading up War and Peace if you inspect a random stranger.

It's hard to translate this in any other way than "I despise knockback please don't add anything that might make it beneficial in any way".

I can't take seriously any argument about "makes it less like real life" in a game where you have people who are immune to bullets, take battle-axes to the FACE and don't care, summon actual demons to fight for them, heal grievous injuries with a wave of their hand, etc. I look at the aggro cap of 17 as reasonable because really beyond that, the person you're trying to fight is already completely surrounded. You can't get into melee range from eveyrone else who's already stacked around him, you can't get in a clear shot anymore, etc. There's so many dogpiling on the tank already that I think it's entirely reasonable and proper for extra mobs to start going after squishies. And at that point, people should have to use their own powers to help themselves and the rest of the team out. Maybe a Kinfender activates Repel and plays goalie, bouncies mobs back to the tank. Or a FF Defender does the same with Force Bolt, etc. Maybe a Blaster briefly toggles Whirlwind for the same effect. Maybe a controller throws Hold's and Immob's. Maybe your scrappers offtank. I do think things die WAY TOO FAST, but that's a separate criticism from whether or not there should be an aggro cap.

I'm not big on the idea of relaxing the level ranges of content. I freely admit, I say this iwth an ulterior motive / something I'm trying to protect. I really don't enjoy lvl 50 teams where everyone is incarnated. It's too much overkill, everything dies instantly, you could replace half (or more!) of the team with a potted plant, and no one would even notice. And I think if you could do any mission at lvl 50, it would rapidly become EXPECTED that everyone did content at level 50, and it would be few and far between to find people who would actually want to exemplar down. That said. Just the same way you get Auto-Exemplar'd if you join a TF or Ouroborus arc, I would be perfectly fine with a lvl 15 character going up to a lvl 30 contact and being automatically sidekicked up to the minimum level range needed for that contact's missions. This would still let you do your content on demand without the "You must be at least this tall for this ride" pain. But it would still ensure that missions were done at proper content levels.

And if you try to knockback Mongo, you'll just make him mad. 🙂 I like it. /signed. would need to experiment for the exact numbers, but I like the idea.

Proposed: Inspiration color: Plaid (red/green? red/blue? red/black? I don't care. but it must be Plaid) Small: name: "Zoom" boost speed cap by 20% (stacks with all movement powers including Afterburner) Medium name: "Fast and Frumious" boost speed cap by 40% (stacks with all movement powers including Afterburner) Large: name: "LUDICROUS SPEED!" boost speed cap by 200%, FORCES user into forward motion AT the new speed cap, for the full duration. User CANNOT stand still or hover in place. User can only stop by dying or by sufficient application of hostile Immob / Hold effects, or by smacking into a wall, and they'll still be running/flying forward into the wall.

There's a nice Vigilante tip mission where you get to put PuppyKicker Weston Phipps in the hospital. You don't get to actually KILL him (stupid railroad plot....), and he manages to twist it for press coverage to garner sympathy.... But he'll be taking food by liquids only for a few weeks while he gets dentures and has his bones heal up in a full body cast. It's *something*, anyway.