Jump to content
The Calendar and Events feature has been re-enabled ×

Focused Feedback: Energy Melee Revamp

Jimmy

By Jimmy
in [Open Beta] Focused Feedback

 Share

Recommended Posts

Recommended

Posted by Jimmy,

As the patch is nearing completion, we are no longer seeking feedback on this topic.   The latest patch notes can be found in the Beta Patch Notes forum.   If you encounter any bugs during this last phase of testing, please report them in the Beta Bug Reports forum.   Once the patch is live, feel free to post feedback in the Suggestions & Feedback forum. and bug reports in the Bug Reports forum.   Thank you!
Recommended by Jimmy

0 reactions

Go to this post
Troo

Troo

Posted
Posted
2 hours ago, Vanden said:

Yes, the guaranteed 1-2 punch for a boss stun cottage has been preserved by moving the 100% chance for single-target stun to Bone Smasher.

I disagree that cottage was persevered here.

 

Bone Smash could stun before, combined with other powers it could stun pretty reliably. Stun could then be used on a different target.

"Homecoming is not perfect but it is still better than the alternative.. at least so far" - Unknown  (Wise words Unknown!)

Si vis pacem, para bellum

Bill Z Bubba

Bill Z Bubba

Posted
Posted

I will say this as a plus for the overall feel: Mandy Marauder feels even more appropriately named when I'm just cutting through spawns using TF/ET/BS/WH/repeat as my chain.

 

Still hate that I'm forced into TF/ET to get the short, old ET punch.

  • Like 2
Golden Azrael

Golden Azrael

Posted
Posted (edited)

Ty Home Coming for LISTENING to the feedback!

 

The mobs.  What a beat down.  It's fast.  It's hard.  It's BOOM-TASTIC!!!

 

Excellent work by the HC team.  Their best work yet.

 

Azrael.

Edited by Golden Azrael
  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
ScarySai

ScarySai

Posted
Posted (edited)

Huge fan of power crash on stalkers, when it's up, it hurts.

 

The focus mechanic is neat too, though I do think it shouldn't be exclusively generated from total focus - it would probably be a balancing nightmare to add that to the other powers in some form, though.

 

Quote

Bone Smash could stun before, combined with other powers it could stun pretty reliably. Stun could then be used on a different target.

Are you unironically defending stun, of all powers here?

Edited by ScarySai
  • Haha 1
Troo

Troo

Posted
Posted (edited)
22 minutes ago, Bill Z Bubba said:

2:50 pylon with EM/SR brute, down from 4:30 on live, using attack chain TF/ET(short)/BS/EP/ET(long)/repeat

Thanks for testing.

 

Yep this or a similar result was going to be had regardless of the method of reducing the animation times of the heavy hitters.

 

Edited by Troo

"Homecoming is not perfect but it is still better than the alternative.. at least so far" - Unknown  (Wise words Unknown!)

Si vis pacem, para bellum

Golden Azrael

Golden Azrael

Posted
Posted (edited)

I love the new Power Crash!  Stacking with WHands!!  Whhoo!

 

And I like the utility coming off the new Energy Boost mechanism.

 

It opens a lot more choice.  BOOM damage.  AoE stun.  BS dis'/stun.

 

Very addictive stuff.

 

I didn't even mind that the artie knives were slowing my attack chain.  'When that Power Crash comes up, ladies...'

 

Azrael.

Edited by Golden Azrael
  • Like 2
  • Thanks 1
Infinitum

Infinitum

Posted
Posted
10 minutes ago, Bill Z Bubba said:

I will say this as a plus for the overall feel: Mandy Marauder feels even more appropriately named when I'm just cutting through spawns using TF/ET/BS/WH/repeat as my chain.

 

Still hate that I'm forced into TF/ET to get the short, old ET punch.

You likely had it as a one two before the nerf though, I did anyway.  

 

All of the updates to EM in this patch places it ahead of old EM by a good stretch.  TF is pretty slick now, there isn't a reason to not use it, and it will usually keep you in fast ET mode.

 

EP was also buffed - that may be a change that gets glossed over in all this but the whole set gained in this.

  • Like 1
ScarySai

ScarySai

Posted
Posted

I'm very eager to see what the people who go really hard on pylon builds cook up for this. With a chain of TF>ET>BS>punch>AS, I was able to get 1:40ish times pretty reliably, and I really doubt that's an optimal chain.

Infinitum

Infinitum

Posted
Posted (edited)

Scrapper EM attack chain

Mix AOE/ST
WH - TF - Fast ET - EP - PC - WH

ST
WH - TF - Fast ET - EP - Fast ET - EP - WH

 

Stalker EM ST chain.

AS - TF - fast ET - EP - AS - EP - Fast ET - EP - AS. 

Edited by Infinitum
  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Myrmidon

Myrmidon

Posted
Posted
28 minutes ago, Troo said:

I disagree that cottage was persevered here.

 

Bone Smash could stun before, combined with other powers it could stun pretty reliably. Stun could then be used on a different target.


Cottage Burn is now a thing.

 

YAY!❤️

  • Thanks 1

Playing CoX is it’s own reward

Bill Z Bubba

Bill Z Bubba

Posted
Posted
23 minutes ago, Infinitum said:

You likely had it as a one two before the nerf though, I did anyway.  

 

All of the updates to EM in this patch places it ahead of old EM by a good stretch.  TF is pretty slick now, there isn't a reason to not use it, and it will usually keep you in fast ET mode.

 

EP was also buffed - that may be a change that gets glossed over in all this but the whole set gained in this.

No, I didn't. My attack chain on all of my lvl 50+ EM users was TF/BS/ET/BS/repeat.

BrandX

BrandX

Posted
Posted (edited)

Haven't gotten on test.  So, looking at just what's given here...

 

Which, EM on Scrappers, I'm going to play regardless.  Let's be honest here.  😛  I've been wanting this since Power Proliferation on live after they ruined (to me anyways) my WP/EM Tank.

 

I wasn't keen on the turning EM into a combo system, but some thoughts...

 

Not sure Bone Smasher needs a -Regen/-Special.  I'm not against it.  However, high ST damage with Stuns was really, all I wanted.  I do like the more chance to actually get stuns going though.

 

Power Crash.  Why not have it remain Stun, but if used with Energy Focus (since this seems to be the idea you're going with) it then delivers Targeted PBAOE (around target) and more damage?  So, keeps the the ST Stun aspect it has now, but if used with Energy Focus it'll get AOE and Damage!

 

Total Focus getting sped up, is what I said needed to be done 🙂  Looks like it's may be around where I thought it should be.  I suggested 2.376 (arcana time), so a littler slower than my suggestion, but part of my suggestion was to also get some alternate animations going on.  Can't say I like the idea of powers not Crit Striking for normal Crit Damage, but it's better than none at all *eyes Concentrated Strike* and if we're stuck with Energy Focus, at least we get two.

 

Energy Transfer costing health instead of endurance.  Love it.  Not sure I care for the idea of making it momentum based.  Couldn't just go 1.848 (arcana time) or some other time, for it all the time and Energy Focus will instead only take 5% of life (this'll give non critters less life lost) and critting can give the user no life lost and +10% Health back as well?  Or just put it's damage at a level were it's okay to crit for normal?  Of course, that may not be good for the Tanks/Brutes.

 

Now to figure out how to make EM/Regen Scrapper work!

 

Edit: As for the -Regen/-Special.  If the idea is to have it, why not just put it in Barrage, since he does less damage than Energy Punch?

Edited by BrandX
  • Like 1
  • Retired Game Master
GM Tock

GM Tock

Posted
  • Retired Game Master
Posted

Focused Feedback threads are under tighter moderation than other places.  Everone, please stay on topic concerning the powers in discussion.

  • Thanks 2

 

 

nihilii

nihilii

Posted
Posted
17 minutes ago, BrandX said:

*eyes Concentrated Strike*

On that note, seeing as Energy Transfer can crit for a special effect and still see that chance to crit affected by +crit bonuses, it would be nice if the same treatment would be applied to CS.

If I'm not making any sense: ET has a 20% chance to heal, the Critical Strikes ATO and the Scrapper Strike ATO will both buff that chance to turn it into a near guaranteed heal.

On the other hand, Concentrated Strike from Kinetic Melee has a flat chance to recharge Build Up on Scrappers, and isn't affected by the Scrapper ATOs. Given that CS is considered a skippable power, I think it could use the help.

  • Like 2
ScarySai

ScarySai

Posted
Posted
3 minutes ago, nihilii said:

On the other hand, Concentrated Strike from Kinetic Melee has a flat chance to recharge Build Up on Scrappers, and isn't affected by the Scrapper ATOs. Given that CS is considered a skippable power, I think it could use the help.

I have a few ideas on how KM could be improved, but this isn't the thread for that.

  • Like 2
AmrasNotHere

AmrasNotHere

Posted
Posted

Not sure if this was addressed for Power Crash, spelling typo in the description while viewing the power at the trainer. Uneashing!!! 🙂

Also Energy Transfer is not showing up under the power section when looking at player info. Really loving the changes so far. 

Build Benchmarks

Bill Z Bubba

Bill Z Bubba

Posted
Posted (edited)

Can anyone tighten up this chain?

 

TF\ET-short\BS\EP\ET-long\repeat Needs 261% total recharge in ET and 209% total in TF.

 

Looks like TF\ET-short\BS\EP\Bar is doable with 289% total rec in TF

Edited by Bill Z Bubba
Super Atom

Super Atom

Posted
Posted (edited)

Good change, needs minor tweaking but overall good change.

 

Not everyone will be happy, but those people can't be helped because they don't want things brought up to fit with modern coh.

Edited by Super Atom
  • Like 3
skoryy

skoryy

Posted
Posted
5 minutes ago, Bill Z Bubba said:

Can anyone tighten up this chain?

 

TF\ET-short\BS\EP\ET-long\repeat Needs 261% total recharge in ET and 209% total in TF.

I've been running TF\ET\BS\EP\Bar, I could imagine something like TF\ET\BS\EP\ET if you have a spare focus, Bar if you don't.

  • Like 1

 Everlasting's Actionette 

Also Wolfhound, Starwave, Blue Gale, Relativity Rabbit, and many more!

Bill Z Bubba

Bill Z Bubba

Posted
Posted
2 minutes ago, skoryy said:

I've been running TF\ET\BS\EP\Bar, I could imagine something like TF\ET\BS\EP\ET if you have a spare focus, Bar if you don't.

How would one get "spare focus?"

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...