I have a lvl 50+9 Vet lvls Super Strength/ Invulnerability Brute.
With all of my lvl 50 IOs and my Incarnate powers running, this is a pretty fun character.
Exemplared down to do a task force, I feel slow and weak. I have fallen into the habit of just not using Rage, which isn't a satisfactory answer. In the meantime, I have made a new non-Super Strength Brute.
I'm very glad to see that a GM has touched base in this thread. Hopefully, it will be decided to just remove the -Def penalty in the crash, but if not I'm glad the community will have a chance to be heard. To that end, my first suggestion is to just remove the -def part of the crash and gather data. If in 6 months' time, Super Strength has overtaken the game and no other kind of characters are being played, then we'll have a proper dataset to tell us where to make adjustments. If not, then leave it alone.
All things aside, I'm so grateful to even have a reason to have this discussion :)